Using secret audio recordings as evidence

The Greek Goddess of Justice, known as Themis.
The Greek Goddess of Justice, known as Themis. Rae Wilson

Colin, aged 77 and Jane, aged 33 have a three-year-old daughter.

Their relationship breaks-down and Jane files an application, seeking property settlement orders under the Family Law Act.

Colin concedes that there was an 18-month sexual relationship between them but says it ended in 2014. He says that the sexual relationship did not constitute a "de facto relationship" claiming that they never had a relationship as a "couple living together on a genuine domestic basis".

Accordingly, Colin claims that the court has no jurisdiction to hear the matter and asks the court to dismiss Jane's application.

Jane produces audio recordings as evidence of the alleged de facto relationship. The recordings were obtained without Colin's knowledge. Colin claims that the recordings were illegally obtained and that they should not be admitted as evidence.

The court notes that the use of a listening device can constitute an offence under the Surveillance Devices Act unless the recording of the conversation is "reasonably necessary for the protection of lawful interests".

The offence is punishable by imprisonment.

The court found that Jane making the recording was in fact, "reasonably necessary" and in the interests of a fair trial, admitted the evidence.

Jane was ordered to prepare a transcript of no more than 6 recordings and to file an affidavit setting out the circumstances surrounding the recording.

The court also made an order, for "more abundant precaution", protecting Jane from criminal prosecution in relation to the making of the recording.

The court made it clear that although the recording would be admitted as evidence, the weight that would be attributed to the evidence was another matter that would be considered in due course.

If you would like Manny to address a particular legal issue, send your request to or call him on (02) 6648 7487.

Regions declared big winners in SCU funding deal

ALL SMILES: Professor Shoemaker is thrilled by the deal struck with the Federal Government.

Funding deal puts Allied Health campus in Coffs back on track

Swimmer missing at Valla while others rescued along Coast

An IRB is searching the waters at Valla Beach for a missing swimmer.

Search for missing man caught in Valla rip will start again at 6am.

Axemen start season with bang in 9s

The Hoey Moey Tooheys Coffs Coast 9s final at Geoff King Motors Park was played between Group 2 rivals the Coffs Harbour Comets and the Orara Valley Axemen who won 12-10. Nines rugby league 17 February 2018 Photo: Brad Greenshields/Coffs Coast Advocate

Promised improvement more than just empty words after Coffs Coast 9s

Local Partners