Business

Using secret audio recordings as evidence

The Greek Goddess of Justice, known as Themis.
The Greek Goddess of Justice, known as Themis. Rae Wilson

Colin, aged 77 and Jane, aged 33 have a three-year-old daughter.

Their relationship breaks-down and Jane files an application, seeking property settlement orders under the Family Law Act.

Colin concedes that there was an 18-month sexual relationship between them but says it ended in 2014. He says that the sexual relationship did not constitute a "de facto relationship" claiming that they never had a relationship as a "couple living together on a genuine domestic basis".

Accordingly, Colin claims that the court has no jurisdiction to hear the matter and asks the court to dismiss Jane's application.

Jane produces audio recordings as evidence of the alleged de facto relationship. The recordings were obtained without Colin's knowledge. Colin claims that the recordings were illegally obtained and that they should not be admitted as evidence.

The court notes that the use of a listening device can constitute an offence under the Surveillance Devices Act unless the recording of the conversation is "reasonably necessary for the protection of lawful interests".

The offence is punishable by imprisonment.

The court found that Jane making the recording was in fact, "reasonably necessary" and in the interests of a fair trial, admitted the evidence.

Jane was ordered to prepare a transcript of no more than 6 recordings and to file an affidavit setting out the circumstances surrounding the recording.

The court also made an order, for "more abundant precaution", protecting Jane from criminal prosecution in relation to the making of the recording.

The court made it clear that although the recording would be admitted as evidence, the weight that would be attributed to the evidence was another matter that would be considered in due course.

If you would like Manny to address a particular legal issue, send your request to manny.wood@ticliblaxland.com.au or call him on (02) 6648 7487.



Granny caught with bottle of bubbly at the wheel

ARRESTED: A 71-year-old woman has been charged with high-range drink driving.

Woman, 71, charged with high-range drink driving.

Investigation into Matthew Mitchell's death gets renewed

INVESTIGATION RENEWED: Peter Mitchell has renewed calls for the public to help find out what happened to his son Matthew.

Appeal for answers to Matthew Mitchell's death renewed

Block out on solar power caused by red tape

Why a third of Coffs Harbour's population can't access solar power.

Why 33% of Coffs' population of 75,275 people can't access solar

Local Partners

Battle for the Ashes in Coffs

What's making news in the Coffs Harbour Council chambers


From little things big things grow

The Coffs Harbour International Buskers and Comedy Festival returns from September 23 to October 1.

Coffs Harbour Buskers and Comedy Festival returns next month.

New developments announced for Curryfest

TASTE TREATS: New developments for Curryfest 2017.

Fresh ideas and developments show no sign of slowing down.

Jemma's bewitching voice

STAGE PRESENCE: Suzie Mathers and Jemma Rix in a scene from Wicked The Musical.

Wicked musical theatre star Jemma Rix has released her debut album.

The two stars who intimidated Chris Hemsworth

HE plays a superhero on the big screen, but Chris Hemsworth has revealed that he was ‘weirdly shaken’ when he met two other big name actors.

Sam Newman: How a Playboy magazine changed everything

The new crew of The Footy Show.Source:Supplied

How a Playboy magazine changed everything.

Leah slams Matty: ‘I was incredibly disappointed’

Leah says she was ‘incredible disappointed’ with Matty J.

BACHELOR evictee's controversial chat with Kyle and Jackie O.

John Eales finds peace with the haka

Inia Maxwell and John Eales in a scene from the documentary John Eales Reveals: The Haka.

Rugby legend is on a quest to learn about a sacred Maori tradition/

The Bachelor recap: Secret pasts publicly exposed

Matty J is left speechless on The Bachelor.

TWO Bachelor contestants’ secret adult pasts have been exposed.

Mother-daughter duo passes Top of the Lake test

Alice Englert, Jane Campion and Nicole Kidman pose for a photograph at the Top of the Lake: China Girl Australian premiere in Sydney.

Alice Englert is a feisty addition to the cast of mum's crime drama.

What's on the big screen this week

Idris Elba in a scene from the movie The Dark Tower.

IDRIS Elba debuts as the Gunslinger in The Dark Tower.

An elegant home, in a coveted location

COASTAL ELEGANCE: This Sapphire beachside home is all about luxury.

The Real Estate Property Guide is online now

Airbnb, Stayz and co tipped to squeeze Coast housing market

HOLIDAY BOOM: Airbnb letting is putting a further squeeze on long-term rentals.

Councils exploring options to manage the industry

Housing estate is almost a sell out

ACTIVITY: Sapphire Beachfront Estate is almost sold out and a hive of construction activity.

It's taken a while, but these beach-front blocks are almost all gone

Looking for a place to start or downsize to?

Come inside Toormina Real Estate's Pick of the Week