NSW politics: Liberal MPs cash in on committees producing little results
NSW politics: Liberal MPs cash in on committees producing little results

Meet the NSW MPs pocketing an extra $10k to do nothing

Some NSW Liberal MPs have been pocketing an extra $10,000 a year to run parliamentary committees that have failed to do any significant work, including one examining the protocol for homeless people in public spaces.

A number of first-term government MPs appointed to chair parliamentary committees are taking home $10,575 per year in additional salary despite those committees failing to produce any reports to state parliament, something Labor has called an "outrageous" political "perk".

Six of parliament's eight lower house committees are chaired by government members. Four of those committees have not produced any reports since the last election in March 2019.

Liberal MP Wendy Lindsay is the chair of a parliamentary committee governing homeless people but hasn’t held any hearings. Picture: AAP Image/Robert Pozo
Liberal MP Wendy Lindsay is the chair of a parliamentary committee governing homeless people but hasn’t held any hearings. Picture: AAP Image/Robert Pozo

 

Shockingly, one inquiry on the go-slow is examining "the protocol for homeless people in public places".

That's despite the fact ­reducing homelessness is a designated "Premier's Priority".

The inquiry relating to homelessness was launched by the Legislative Assembly Committee on Community Services in October, four months after first-term ­Liberal MP Wendy Lindsay was appointed chair.

The inquiry has not held any hearings, with two scheduled for August.

In a statement, the East Hills MP said "committee processes were disrupted because of the (COVID-19) pandemic".

Labor MP Rose Jackson said it was "outrageous" that committee chairs were getting extra pay "without any accountability over what work they've actually done".

 

Liberal MP for Goulburn Wendy Tuckerman, whose law and safety committee has been slow to complete its work. Picture: Kym Smith
Liberal MP for Goulburn Wendy Tuckerman, whose law and safety committee has been slow to complete its work. Picture: Kym Smith

 

Another committee under the spotlight, the Law and Safety Committee, began its first inquiry of this parliamentary term in March - almost eight months after Goulburn MP Wendy Tuckerman was appointed chair.

No hearings have yet been scheduled for its inquiry into the "physical health of police and emergency services workers in NSW".

Submissions to the inquiry would close in August, after a number of stakeholders requested an extension, Ms Tuckerman said.

 

The transport committee, chaired by Robyn Preston, has delayed a field inspection of electric buses. Picture: AAP Image/Mark Scott
The transport committee, chaired by Robyn Preston, has delayed a field inspection of electric buses. Picture: AAP Image/Mark Scott

 

Ms Tuckerman said she had also requested a committee meeting to consider Police Minister David Elliott's request for an urgent inquiry into assaults on police.

The Transport and Infrastructure Committee, chaired by Liberal Robyn Preston, began an inquiry into electric buses in October. This inquiry held two hearings in March. A further "field inspection of electric buses" had been delayed amid COVID-19, Ms Preston said.

She said the committee was working on a draft report.

The Parliamentary Privilege and Ethics Committee, chaired by Liberal Peter Sidgreaves, is not conducting a single inquiry.

Mr Sidgreaves said the committee was "currently looking at a number of matters (that) are confidential until the committee tables the report".

 

Liberal MP Peter Sidgreaves is the chair of the parliamentary ethics committee.
Liberal MP Peter Sidgreaves is the chair of the parliamentary ethics committee.

 

Ms Jackson said government MPs had been given roles chairing committees "as part of an 'everyone wins a prize' approach to parliamentary perks".

It's not just Liberal MPs pocketing extra cash without producing reports: Independent MP Alex Greenwich's Environment and Planning Committee started an inquiry into "sustainability of energy supply and resources in NSW" in July last year but has not held a single hearing.

Despite submissions for that inquiry closing in September, Mr Greenwich blamed the delay in holding any hearings on COVID-19. He said he hoped to begin hearings in August.

In contrast, the lower house Committee on Investment, Industry & Regional Development chaired by Liberal Justin Clancy has already produced an interim report for its inquiry into support for drought-affected communities.

That inquiry began in September last year, and held two online hearings in May.

Independent Lake Macquarie MP Greg Piper's Public Accounts Committee has launched five inquiries, of which four have produced ­reports.

 

Independent MP Alex Greenwich is also taking his time as chair of the environment and planning committee. Picture: AAP Image/Joel Carrett
Independent MP Alex Greenwich is also taking his time as chair of the environment and planning committee. Picture: AAP Image/Joel Carrett

 

Ms Jackson said parliamentary committees "play an important role" by exploring "complex policy" and making "detailed recommendations".

"If MPs are putting in the work, they should be paid appropriately," she said.

"What the public hates is when politicians get perks that aren't linked to any actual work."

Richard Sharvin, 64, who has slept under the bridge at Wentworth Park for 10 years on and off, said he was angry that an MP was being paid an extra $10,000 to investigate homelessness but had failed to do anything.

 

Homeless man Richard Sharvin says the MPs running the inquiry should see how he lives. Picture: Brett Costello
Homeless man Richard Sharvin says the MPs running the inquiry should see how he lives. Picture: Brett Costello

 

"It's money that should be going to people who need it," he said.

"We're the low ones. They should get out of their offices and come down here and talk face-to-face. Why not get out of their own little luxury and come down? See how we live."

He said services had not improved recently.

"The Salvos come every Wednesday and give us a hot meal and water," he said.

"Every now and then state housing comes by. Police come when they're looking for someone. And the nurse comes and checks on us. That's about it."

Raymond Griffiths, 54, who has slept rough in Sydney for 20 years, said homelessness had become an "industry" for the government to make money without addressing the problems.

 

Homeless man Raymond Griffiths says homelessness is too big an industry for MPs to really want to fix it. Picture: Brett Costello
Homeless man Raymond Griffiths says homelessness is too big an industry for MPs to really want to fix it. Picture: Brett Costello

 

"They don't really want us off the streets. What are they going to do about jobs then?" Mr Griffiths said.

"A bus comes down here on the weekend, comes down with showers and toilets. Only four people go and use it. It's all a waste of money."

Originally published as Meet the NSW MPs pocketing an extra $10k to do nothing



‘Unconscionable’ Gooley slams Park Beach contribution plan

Premium Content ‘Unconscionable’ Gooley slams Park Beach contribution plan

“It would be unconscionable and jeopardise our ability to develop site.”

‘INHUMANE’: Toddler murderer’s appeal bid rejected

Premium Content ‘INHUMANE’: Toddler murderer’s appeal bid rejected

‘Brutal, callous and inhumane’ were the words used to describe the shocking murder...

UPDATE: 7yo trapped in crash flown out by chopper

Premium Content UPDATE: 7yo trapped in crash flown out by chopper

Car crashes into tree leaving girl with serious injuries