Should meat eaters be targeted in a campaign to encourage them to eat less or no meat?
Should meat eaters be targeted in a campaign to encourage them to eat less or no meat? Contributed

Meat eaters ought to be treated like smokers, says UK MP

MEAT eaters should be treated in the same way as smokers and targeted with ad campaigns urging them to become vegetarians, according to Labour's new spokeswoman for the farming industry.

Kerry McCarthy, who has admitted she is a "militant" vegan, was appointed shadow environment secretary in Jeremy Corbyn's front-bench team, alarming countryside campaigners who warned that her veganism and strong opposition to hunting and the badger cull would harm Britain's farming industry.

She said that although progress had been made to improve animal welfare, ultimately people needed to give up meat or dairy if they really wanted to protect animals.

Public campaigns, such as those warning of the dangers of smoking, should be used to encourage people to give up meat, Ms McCarthy said.

But her views were dismissed as "verging on the cranky" by the Countryside Alliance, who have warned Mr Corbyn that Ms McCarthy's appointment has made distanced farmers even further from the Labour party.

Should public campaigns be used to encourage people to give up meat?

This poll ended on 20 January 2016.

Current Results





This is not a scientific poll. The results reflect only the opinions of those who chose to participate.

Ms McCarthy has been a vegan for the last 20 years and was a vegetarian for 10 years before that. She has also campaigned against the Government's badger cull and fox hunting in her role as vice-president of the League Against Cruel Sports.

In an interview with vegan magazine Viva!life, she said: "I really believe that meat should be treated in exactly the same way as tobacco, with public campaigns to stop people eating it.

"Progress on animal welfare is being made at EU level … but in the end it comes down to not eating meat or dairy."

Jeremy Corbyn's decision to appoint a vegan in charge of Labour's dealings with farmers disappointed some in the industry

In another move that is likely to anger farmers, she said the low price of milk in the UK was "a supply and demand thing", adding: "Too much milk is being produced and if you live by the market you have to risk dying by the market."

Ms McCarthy said the use of EU farming subsidies to fund shooting and forestry had turned her into an even more radical vegan.

"The constant challenging of the environmental impact of livestock farming is making me more and more militant, not least that CAP payments are available for grouse shooting, controlling buzzards and forestry," she said.

A British politician believes meat eaters should be treated like smokers.
A British politician believes meat eaters should be treated like smokers. Trevor Veale

She defended Mr Corbyn's decision to appoint someone with such strong opinions to the role, saying it was "important to have someone in the role who doesn't see it as a stepping stone to a different post, but is really keen to get engaged in the issues."

She added: "There will be different viewpoints, there will be violent disagreements, but it's about trying to listen to the evidence, approach things with an open mind - and I am very much prepared to do that."

Tim Bonner, from the Countryside Alliance, said: "Kerry McCarthy's views on meat eating and livestock farming are completely out of step with the vast majority of people.

"Her ideas are verging on the cranky. This appointment is only going to make it more difficult for Jeremy Corbyn's Labour Party to reconnect with rural Britain."

Ms McCarthy later sought to reassure the farming industry by clarifying her comments. She told Radio 4's Farming Today: The world is not going to turn vegan because I am in post.

"I have my own personal views on what I choose to eat, but I accept that we have a livestock industry in this country. What I want is for the industry to have the best welfare standards possible, to be sustainable as well as economically viable."

What do you think about this? Should meat eaters in Australia be treated like smokers and targeted with ad campaigns urging them to become vegetarians? 

Join our daily watercooler by leaving a comment below.

What you're saying on Facebook:

Simon Hourigan: "More people eat meat than there are vegetarians. So maybe vegetarians should be advertised to eat meet."

Sarah Holyland: "I think we should let people eat whatever they want to eat. Instead we should be looking at the way in which we get our meat all those animals being abused. Pigs are one of the most abused animals on earth just so we can have bacon. We should be looking at a supermarket shelves and trying to put food back on them instead of food - like items."

Lesly Williams: :What right have they got to control what they eat? Eating red meat is entirely different to smoking."

Jared Lawlor: "If vegetarians love animals so much, why do they eat all their food?"

Diane McCudden: "I would be more concerned about sugar and fats."

Melissa Brown: "Why should people be forced to pay to have the liberty/freedom to eat whatever the hell they want taken away from them....yeah no. Not happening."

Sam Owen: "What a joke..."

Gary Marr: "When you think about the production and consumption of mass produced meat, the cons outweigh the pros."

Zach Sweeney: "This is ridiculous."

Harry Williamson: "Ahahaha ummm, let me think about that for a second... NOPE! Humans have eaten meat since we were cavemen & hunters and gatherers."

Ray Feltman: "Just shows they are totally out of touch with reality."

Joshuah Riley: "Bugger off! We have enough "nanning" in this country as it is."

Motorbike rider critical after Coffs smash

Premium Content Motorbike rider critical after Coffs smash

A Urunga man remains in a critical condition after a motorcycle crash near Coffs...

LOCAL NEWS MATTERS: $1 a week for first 12 weeks

Premium Content LOCAL NEWS MATTERS: $1 a week for first 12 weeks

Deal gives you access to local, regional and metro News sites

Premier left ‘heartened’ by our local heroes

Premium Content Premier left ‘heartened’ by our local heroes

Coffs Coast locals have been awarded by the Premier for their selfless dedication...