News

Lawyers and Coalition at odds on CCTV cameras

Law experts are questioning the value of a Coalition pledge to spend $50 million on CCTV coverage if elected.
Law experts are questioning the value of a Coalition pledge to spend $50 million on CCTV coverage if elected. Karleila Thomsen

A LEADING lawyer's group has cautioned against a Coalition promise to spend millions on close surveillance if elected to government in 2013.

The Australian Lawyers Alliance says that the pledge to spend $50 million for additional CCTV cameras around Australia to monitor people's movements does not take account of privacy concerns and potential misuse of cameras to profile groups and individuals.

Opposition frontbencher and Nationals Member for Cowper, Luke Hartsuyker, this week outlined a scheme where North Coast communities will be able to apply for crime prevention infrastructure such as better lighting, as well as fixed and mobile CCTV coverage.

He said the money would help tackle crime hotspots and help deal with the problems of gangs, graffiti and alcohol-fuelled violence.

But ALA spokesman and criminal barrister, Greg Barns, said the plan to monitor people's lives came at a cost to civil liberties and created the potential for human rights violations.

"The cameras were likely to be misused with innocent people and community groups likely to be unlawfully surveilled, on occasions, breaching privacy rights," he said.

"A line definitely needs to be drawn in the sand as to where these cameras are installed and public accountability for authorities accessing footage without due cause.

"Such 'reason for access' provisions had been introduced into state-based police forces to ensure police officers did not abuse their abilities to surveil and this should also be standard practice with any footage viewed."

The Coalition plainly disagrees.

"The best way to tackle crime and anti-social behaviour is to prevent it happening," Mr Hartsuyker said.

"The prevention of crime means less senseless deaths and needless injuries and it means reduced costs in the justice system."



Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Strange Politics: Peter Dutton treats refugees like rubbish

Strange Politics: Immigration Minister Peter Dutton makes an awful neighbour.

My mad old bin-phobic neighbour's kindred spirit in Peter Dutton

Coffs PCYC to add a hub for youth

BOOST: The Coffs Harbour PCYC has been granted $9120 for a Youth Hub.

PCYC awarded $9120 by the Federal Government for a youth hub

Please no patting: I have a job to do

RESPECT MY UNIFORM: Local guide dog handler Sally Jary and her dog Kent are joining fire fighters in reminding the public not to pat guide dogs in uniform.

Distracting a working guide dog could have disastrous consequences

Latest deals and offers


Million dollar ice seizure in Coffs Harbour

Coffs-Clarence LAC crime manager Detective Inspector Darren Jameson briefs the...

Rally Australia Chair Ben Rainsford

Kennards Hire Rally Australia will bring spectacular world rally action back to the NSW Coffs Coast on November 17-20.

Rally Australia Chairman Ben Rainsford comments on Coffs Harbour City Council...

AFL North Coast preview

BACK IN THE FOLD: Grafton’s Josh Lollback returns to the line-up for today’s knockout semi final clash against Port Macquarie. Photo: Debrah Novak/Daily Examiner

Paul Taylor and Allanah Hanson take a look at the AFL North Coast news ahead of...

Renting harder in Coffs than Sydney

HIGH DEMAND: Coffs Harbour rental properties are in higher demand than in Sydney.

Coffs Harbour’s rental vacancy rate at lowest level in eight years

How a sacked real estate agent made $725k in four months

Agent is now under investigation by the industry watchdog

VIDEO: Art Deco fan pays $835,000 for Imperial Hotel

No Caption

Iconic "Impy" sold at a bargan price to bidder who loves Art Deco.